College Football's Expanded Playoff Works. Its Rhythm Doesn't.

The College Football Playoff (CFP) has entered its second season with an expanded format, featuring 12 teams instead of the previous format's four. This expansion was designed to give more teams the opportunity to compete for the national championship, moving away from decisions based on rankings and selections made in committee rooms. This season's championship game will feature Indiana, an undefeated team, against the 10th-seeded Miami, with the game set to take place at Miami's home stadium.

Despite the increased excitement and opportunities for more teams, the expanded playoff has contributed to a growing sense of disarray among college football fans. A poll conducted by The Athletic found that 56% of respondents are discontent with the current state of college football, citing issues such as the influence of money, the impact of NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) deals, and the transfer portal. These elements have contributed to a perception that college football is increasingly resembling professional sports.

The expanded playoff format has also affected